Results of the 2011 – 2012 Bowl Pick-em Strategy
As you may know, I posted my strategy for picking College Football Bowl winners. I broke them down into several categories:
- Home Teams
- Playing Absent Coaches
- Playing Little Sisters of the Poor
- Better Records Last year
- Playing teams I watched Lay Eggs throughout the year
- Toss Ups
Turns out one strategy was superior to the others: Teams playing absent coaches
Teams playing others with their coach either getting fired or leaving for another opportunity were vastly superior bets vs. the spread this year. If you picked solely against absent coaches, you would have gone 6-of-7, and would have lost the 7th game by 0.5 points.
One other strategy played out the opposite of what I expected: Little Sisters of the Poor went 2-0 against big conferences.
The rest of the strategies were break-even at best. Betting on the home team yielded a 56% win %, and toss ups were indeed toss-ups (50%). Teams playing ones I considered “Egg Layers” went 2-1, but the small sample size was not convincing.
So next year, when you’re formulating your Bowl pool, pick against the teams that lost their coach, and steer clear of the rest.